Quantum computing: Brussels can move the date. The other clocks keep ticking

Con quello che leggerete di seguito, avviamo la pubblicazione in lingua originale inglese di Notes from the Edge, una serie ideata e scritta da Antonio Amendola e pubblicata su LinkedIn. La newsletter esplora la relazione tra nuove tecnologie, potere e geopolitica e offre considerazioni sulla tensione tra chi promuove l’adozione di nuove soluzioni tecnologiche, le imprese, e chi determina le regole con cui produrle, diffonderle e utilizzarle in ambito comunitario, la Commissione europea. L’idea è di restituire un quadro più preciso delle discussioni che ruotano intorno alla formazione delle regole sul settore. Regole che avranno un impatto diretto sui sistemi economici e sulle vite delle imprese, non importa di quale grandezza, in ogni angolo d’Europa e quindi anche nel nostro. Il punto di vista è inevitabilmente parziale, ma l’autorevolezza dell’autore e l’importanza del tema superano di gran lunga la tentazione dell’autocensura. Amendola ha un’esperienza di quasi trent’anni nel settore delle telecomunicazioni. Ha lavorato all’Agcom, ha ricoperto ruoli apicali in diversi ministeri italiani e ha guidato per 8 anni gli affari esterni internazionali di AT&T a Bruxelles. Da quasi 4 anni è a capo del team sulla Comunicazione strategica e Tecnologia, Media e Telecomunicazioni di FTI Consulting, sempre a Bruxelles.
I collegamenti ipertestuali sono quelli originali.


The European Commission was due to present its Quantum Act on 18 November. The date now pencilled in is 24 November, in Strasbourg. In Brussels, that gives us another week to speculate about the text.

It also made me think of an interview I’d just listened to with Simon Patkovic, who works on quantum security at IonQ. He describes the move to post-quantum cryptography as a problem of four clocks that don’t agree. And I’m very much aligned on that dealignment..

We spend a lot of time talking about when a quantum computer might be able to break today’s cryptography. The people who have to replace it are already working to several different deadlines.

  1. There’s the regulator’s clock. Europe already has a roadmap: Member States should start the transition by the end of 2026 and protect high-risk uses by the end of 2030.
  2. Then there’s the adversary’s clock. Someone who can intercept your encrypted traffic can keep a copy today and try to read it years from now (Does Harvest now, decrypt later rings a bell?). If the data will still be sensitive then, the risk starts when the copy is made.
  3. The vendor’s clock runs on product releases. An upgrade may be available for the newest model and still be months away for the equipment you actually run.
  4. And then there’s your own clock. Who owns the budget? Who has the skills to test the upgrade? When can you touch a system that’s supposed to be up all the time?

That last clock is the one I keep coming back to every time I have a conversation on quantum with companies.

Imagine that on Monday your security team starts an inventory of everything that needs to migrate. On Friday, procurement signs a contract for network equipment you’ll be running for the next seven years. Did anyone ask how its cryptography can be updated?

You can be making progress on Monday and adding to the job on Friday. Both teams can be doing exactly what they were asked to do.

That’s why I’ll be looking for the procurement provision when the Quantum Act comes out. In the leaked draft, Article 25 raised the prospect of making post-quantum readiness a condition for certain public purchases in critical sectors. If it survives, the detail I want to see is what a supplier has to demonstrate. Can the buyer update the cryptography when standards change? How long will the supplier support that update? Will it take a software release or a new piece of hardware?

If I were putting this on a board agenda, I’d start with one contract renewal. Bring in the people who buy the equipment and the people who’ll have to upgrade it. Ask them to walk through what happens if the cryptography needs to change halfway through the contract.

Have that conversation before the renewal. It’s a much better time to find out you need a different deal.

ARTICOLI CORRELATI